Protecting Commercial Investment On Mars: The Limits of Extending International Arbitration To Conflicts in Space and Possible Ways Forward

Written bY: 
Published 
May 4, 2021

Protecting Commercial Investment On Mars: The Limits of Extending International Arbitration To Conflicts in Space and Possible Ways Forward

Abstract

Existing international arbitration agreements offer a valid mechanism for resolving commercial disputes in space. One recent ruling in CC/Devas, in particular, offers a key precedent for resolving the legal issue posed because the physical location of a space investment is not geographically within the host country (which is customary for ISDS jurisdiction). However, international arbitration is unlikely to resolve major commercial disputes because of the dual-use nature of space technology, encroaching protectionism in the name of national security, and reemergent great power competition. One way to buttress the private space sector from national security risks and supply chain shocks, while encouraging more entrepreneurial activity in space, would be to form public-private partnerships, offer grants, and offer guarantees against insolvency resulting from research and development in areas prioritized by NASA.

Citation

Holtzman, Clare., Schrader, Sam. (2021). Protecting Commercial Investment On Mars: The Limits of Extending International Arbitration To Conflicts in Space and Possible Ways Forward. 1st Edition. [Word] Durham: Duke University, 12 pages. Available at Link

Download
File Size
45.5 kB
File Type
Word
Full Mission Profile

Post You Might Also Like

All Posts
Commerce
May 3, 2021

Analysis of Commercial Funding Strategies for the Settlement of Mars

Medicine
May 3, 2021

Ultrasound Based Autonomous Systems can help Mitigate Medical Risk on Deep Space Missions

Autonomous systems can help mitigate health risks on a large duration space mission in specific cases/scenarios. The risk tradeoffs of extra medical personnel versus autonomous systems will be explored specifically in the NASA identified list of medical conditions that could be detected by diagnosis by ultrasound. Autonomous ultrasound image collection and detection will be explored separately for these enumerated conditions and recommendations will be made based on timing of onset and duration of conditions, efficacy and utility of diagnosis for ultrasound, and training capability that could be offloaded to an autonomous system versus a crew expertise requirement for launch.
Governance
May 3, 2021

Systems for Resource Equality in Martian Society from Foundation to Independence

Governance
May 3, 2021

Inter-State Cooperation on Mars: Institutional Incentives for Collaboration

Commerce
May 4, 2021

Protecting Commercial Investment On Mars: The Limits of Extending International Arbitration To Conflicts in Space and Possible Ways Forward

International arbitration offers a promising long-term framework for resolving commercial disputes in space, but in the short-term governments may rely more on public private partnerships because of reemergent national security concerns over dual-use technology.

follow the mission

Get our emails to stay in the know